Traeger Pro 575
The Traeger Pro 575 is positioned as the market leader for garden pellet grills thanks to its reliable WiFIRE connectivity and consistent temperature control that make it easy to manage long smokes from a backyard setup. Its polished app-driven experience and broad dealer support justify a higher price compared with the others on this list, while still delivering predictable pellet efficiency and low-maintenance operation ideal for regular garden use.
Wi‑Fi control magic
Consistent smoke
Wi‑Fi control magic
Consistent smoke
Review Summary
"Users praise its reliable temperature control, consistent smoke flavor and the Traeger app, while some report occasional electronic glitches and lower-than-expected sear capability."
Pellet-hopper ease
575 sq. in. cooking area suits family meals and garden parties.
Pellet-hopper ease
575 sq. in. cooking area suits family meals and garden parties.
Time-Saving Convenience
The Traeger Pro 575 is positioned as the market leader for garden pellet grills thanks to its reliable WiFIRE connectivity and consistent temperature control that make it easy to manage long smokes from a backyard setup. Its polished app-driven experience and broad dealer support justify a higher price compared with the others on this list, while still delivering predictable pellet efficiency and low-maintenance operation ideal for regular garden use.
Wi‑Fi control magic
Consistent smoke
Pellet-hopper ease
575 sq. in. cooking area suits family meals and garden parties.
WiFIRE app control for remote temperature and cook monitoring.
Wi‑Fi control magic
Consistent smoke
Pellet-hopper ease
575 sq. in. cooking area suits family meals and garden parties.
WiFIRE app control for remote temperature and cook monitoring.
$1,200-1,600 CAD
Pit Boss Navigator 850
The Pit Boss Navigator 850 earns a best-in-class value spot for garden pellet grilling by combining a large hopper and cooking area with a budget-friendly price, giving gardeners more capacity per dollar than many competitors. While it lacks the polished app ecosystem of Traeger or Camp Chef, its straightforward controls and generous fuel capacity make it an economical choice for frequent outdoor cooks who prioritize roast volume over smart features.
Massive cookspace party
Dual-zone versatility
Massive cookspace party
Dual-zone versatility
Review Summary
"Buyers like the large cooking area and strong value proposition, but many note uneven temperature consistency and durability issues over long-term use."
Value-packed grill
Generous ~850 sq. in. cooking surface for multi-rack cooking.
Value-packed grill
Generous ~850 sq. in. cooking surface for multi-rack cooking.
Time-Saving Convenience
The Pit Boss Navigator 850 earns a best-in-class value spot for garden pellet grilling by combining a large hopper and cooking area with a budget-friendly price, giving gardeners more capacity per dollar than many competitors. While it lacks the polished app ecosystem of Traeger or Camp Chef, its straightforward controls and generous fuel capacity make it an economical choice for frequent outdoor cooks who prioritize roast volume over smart features.
Massive cookspace party
Dual-zone versatility
Value-packed grill
Generous ~850 sq. in. cooking surface for multi-rack cooking.
Digital temperature controller for steady, reliable cooks.
Massive cookspace party
Dual-zone versatility
Value-packed grill
Generous ~850 sq. in. cooking surface for multi-rack cooking.
Digital temperature controller for steady, reliable cooks.
Weber SmokeFire EX4
The Weber SmokeFire EX4 stands out in the garden market as the premium searing-focused pellet grill, offering a robust build and direct flame capability that rivals traditional gas or charcoal performance in a compact footprint. It commands a higher price but delivers superior sear, durable materials and a familiar Weber warranty/service network—advantages for gardeners who want high-heat versatility alongside smoking performance.
Flash sear power
Premium Weber build
Flash sear power
Premium Weber build
Review Summary
"Owners love its high-heat searing ability, solid build and Weber ecosystem, though a minority report firmware/connectivity bugs and higher pellet consumption."
Deep wood smoke
High-heat capability up to about 600°F for excellent steak searing.
Deep wood smoke
High-heat capability up to about 600°F for excellent steak searing.
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
Time-Saving Convenience
The Weber SmokeFire EX4 stands out in the garden market as the premium searing-focused pellet grill, offering a robust build and direct flame capability that rivals traditional gas or charcoal performance in a compact footprint. It commands a higher price but delivers superior sear, durable materials and a familiar Weber warranty/service network—advantages for gardeners who want high-heat versatility alongside smoking performance.
Flash sear power
Premium Weber build
Deep wood smoke
High-heat capability up to about 600°F for excellent steak searing.
Porcelain-coated cast-iron grates deliver even heat and great sear marks.
Flash sear power
Premium Weber build
Deep wood smoke
High-heat capability up to about 600°F for excellent steak searing.
Porcelain-coated cast-iron grates deliver even heat and great sear marks.
$1,300-1,700 CAD
Camp Chef Woodwind WiFi 24
The Camp Chef Woodwind WiFi 24 is notable for combining precise temperature control, integrated Wi-Fi and modular accessories (like sear and sidekick options) that make it extremely adaptable for garden cooks wanting both smoking and direct-heat grilling. Technically competitive with Traeger on smart features, it often offers better value through accessory compatibility and stronger direct-heat options, appealing to users who expect workshop-style versatility in their backyard setup.
Auto-feed auger
Sidekick-ready versatility
Auto-feed auger
Sidekick-ready versatility
Review Summary
"Reviewers appreciate accurate temps, versatile features (sidekick/slide-and-sear) and good smoke, with occasional complaints about Wi‑Fi reliability and customer service responses."
App control convenience
24-inch cooking surface (around 570 sq. in.) ideal for weekend garden cooks.
App control convenience
24-inch cooking surface (around 570 sq. in.) ideal for weekend garden cooks.
Time-Saving Convenience
The Camp Chef Woodwind WiFi 24 is notable for combining precise temperature control, integrated Wi-Fi and modular accessories (like sear and sidekick options) that make it extremely adaptable for garden cooks wanting both smoking and direct-heat grilling. Technically competitive with Traeger on smart features, it often offers better value through accessory compatibility and stronger direct-heat options, appealing to users who expect workshop-style versatility in their backyard setup.
Auto-feed auger
Sidekick-ready versatility
App control convenience
24-inch cooking surface (around 570 sq. in.) ideal for weekend garden cooks.
Wi‑Fi enabled precise temperature control for remote adjustments.
Auto-feed auger
Sidekick-ready versatility
App control convenience
24-inch cooking surface (around 570 sq. in.) ideal for weekend garden cooks.
Wi‑Fi enabled precise temperature control for remote adjustments.
$1,200-1,600 CAD
Broil King Regal Pellet 500
The Broil King Regal Pellet 500 brings heavy-duty construction and a spacious cooking area to the garden pellet grill segment, delivering a premium stainless feel and strong thermal mass that helps steady temperatures in variable outdoor conditions. Priced competitively against Weber and Traeger, it provides a solid middle ground for buyers seeking grill-like build quality and searing capability without the top-tier premium, making it a practical choice for durable garden use.
Precision temp control
Sturdy cast-iron feel
Precision temp control
Sturdy cast-iron feel
Review Summary
"Users highlight robust construction, good grill/smoke performance and strong sear, but some experience app/temperature-control hiccups and limited dealer support."
Rich smoke flavor
Robust stainless-steel build and multi-level cooking space for large gatherings.
Rich smoke flavor
Robust stainless-steel build and multi-level cooking space for large gatherings.
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
The Broil King Regal Pellet 500 brings heavy-duty construction and a spacious cooking area to the garden pellet grill segment, delivering a premium stainless feel and strong thermal mass that helps steady temperatures in variable outdoor conditions. Priced competitively against Weber and Traeger, it provides a solid middle ground for buyers seeking grill-like build quality and searing capability without the top-tier premium, making it a practical choice for durable garden use.
Precision temp control
Sturdy cast-iron feel
Rich smoke flavor
Robust stainless-steel build and multi-level cooking space for large gatherings.
Electronic PID-style controller keeps temperatures steady for long smokes.
Precision temp control
Sturdy cast-iron feel
Rich smoke flavor
Robust stainless-steel build and multi-level cooking space for large gatherings.
Electronic PID-style controller keeps temperatures steady for long smokes.