Brinly-Hardy PRC-24BH 270-Pound Combination Push/Tow Poly Lawn Roller
Brinly-Hardy’s PRC-24BH claims best-in-class versatility as a 270-pound combination push/tow poly roller, delivering substantial compaction while avoiding the rust and maintenance of steel. It offers a stronger weight-to-maintenance balance than lighter poly models like Agri-Fab and more convenience than large steel rollers such as Yard Commander and Ohio Steel, making it a cost-effective choice for homeowners who need serious flattening without industrial upkeep.
270-pound power
Push or tow
270-pound power
Push or tow
Review Summary
"Users generally praise the Brinly-Hardy PRC-24BH for its rust-proof poly drum, good balance of weight (270 lb when filled) and tow/push versatility, making it effective for seeding and leveling; a few users report minor assembly hassles and that it lacks the compaction power of heavier steel rollers. Overall owners find it reliable for routine lawn work but not for heavy commercial compaction."
Poly magic glide
270-pound filled weight for strong compaction and leveling
Poly magic glide
270-pound filled weight for strong compaction and leveling
Time-Saving Convenience
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
Brinly-Hardy’s PRC-24BH claims best-in-class versatility as a 270-pound combination push/tow poly roller, delivering substantial compaction while avoiding the rust and maintenance of steel. It offers a stronger weight-to-maintenance balance than lighter poly models like Agri-Fab and more convenience than large steel rollers such as Yard Commander and Ohio Steel, making it a cost-effective choice for homeowners who need serious flattening without industrial upkeep.
270-pound power
Push or tow
Poly magic glide
270-pound filled weight for strong compaction and leveling
Poly drum resists rust, dents and cold-weather cracking
270-pound power
Push or tow
Poly magic glide
270-pound filled weight for strong compaction and leveling
Poly drum resists rust, dents and cold-weather cracking
$300-450 CAD
Agri-Fab 45-0267 18x24 Poly Push/Tow Lawn Roller
Agri-Fab’s 45-0267 18x24 poly push/tow roller is the budget-minded market leader for typical residential use, giving easy towing, low maintenance, and wide retail availability. While it lacks the raw mass of Brinly-Hardy or steel models, its lower price and lightweight handling make it the most economical option for small yards and seasonal tasks.
Compact 18x24
Easy hitch swap
Compact 18x24
Easy hitch swap
Review Summary
"The Agri-Fab 45-0267 is widely regarded as a good-value, easy-to-use poly push/tow roller that's convenient to fill and maneuver for residential yards, though some buyers have reported occasional valve leaks or plastic cracking after long-term use. Most users are satisfied for typical seeding and light leveling tasks but note it isn't as robust as steel models."
Never-rust poly
18x24-inch poly drum is lightweight empty and fills for adjustable weight
Never-rust poly
18x24-inch poly drum is lightweight empty and fills for adjustable weight
Time-Saving Convenience
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
Agri-Fab’s 45-0267 18x24 poly push/tow roller is the budget-minded market leader for typical residential use, giving easy towing, low maintenance, and wide retail availability. While it lacks the raw mass of Brinly-Hardy or steel models, its lower price and lightweight handling make it the most economical option for small yards and seasonal tasks.
Compact 18x24
Easy hitch swap
Never-rust poly
18x24-inch poly drum is lightweight empty and fills for adjustable weight
Designed for both push and tow use with a simple hitch and handle
Compact 18x24
Easy hitch swap
Never-rust poly
18x24-inch poly drum is lightweight empty and fills for adjustable weight
Designed for both push and tow use with a simple hitch and handle
$220-350 CAD
Yard Commander YTF-42PR 42-Inch Steel Lawn Roller
The Yard Commander YTF-42PR 42-inch steel roller is positioned as a professional-grade steel option that excels at deeper compaction across larger turf areas, outperforming poly rollers in flattening and long-term structural work. It trades the corrosion resistance and lighter transport of poly models for superior durability and weight, though it requires more maintenance and sits below the heavier-duty Ohio Steel 60T in raw mass and commercial capacity.
Steel heavyweight
42-inch sweep
Steel heavyweight
42-inch sweep
Review Summary
"Owners appreciate the Yard Commander YTF-42PR's large 42-inch steel drum and strong compaction performance for heavier jobs, but many comment on its heavy weight making it difficult to move by hand and a tendency to show surface rust or paint wear over time. It’s favored for serious yard work where durability and compaction matter, with caveats on maneuverability and maintenance."
Rolls like thunder
42-inch welded steel drum covers large areas quickly
Rolls like thunder
42-inch welded steel drum covers large areas quickly
Time-Saving Convenience
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
The Yard Commander YTF-42PR 42-inch steel roller is positioned as a professional-grade steel option that excels at deeper compaction across larger turf areas, outperforming poly rollers in flattening and long-term structural work. It trades the corrosion resistance and lighter transport of poly models for superior durability and weight, though it requires more maintenance and sits below the heavier-duty Ohio Steel 60T in raw mass and commercial capacity.
Steel heavyweight
42-inch sweep
Rolls like thunder
42-inch welded steel drum covers large areas quickly
Heavy-duty steel construction delivers consistent weight for seedbed prep and leveling
Steel heavyweight
42-inch sweep
Rolls like thunder
42-inch welded steel drum covers large areas quickly
Heavy-duty steel construction delivers consistent weight for seedbed prep and leveling
$800-1200 CAD
Garant GPLR24 24-Inch Push Lawn Roller
Garant’s GPLR24 24-inch push lawn roller is a compact, premium build favored for tight lawns and precision work, offering a sturdier, longer-lasting finish than similarly sized poly rollers. It typically costs more per inch than mass-market poly units but provides better longevity and a corrosion-resistant finish that bridges the gap between inexpensive poly models and full steel machines.
24-inch precision
Fine finish compactor
24-inch precision
Fine finish compactor
Review Summary
"The Garant GPLR24 is commonly described as a well-built, easy-to-assemble 24-inch roller that handles seeding and leveling tasks reliably for homeowners; reviewers highlight solid construction and good value, while a minority note occasional issues with the drain/fill valve or minor dents after heavy use. Overall it’s seen as a dependable mid-size roller for residential use."
Agile push control
24-inch drum sized for residential lawns and tighter spaces
Agile push control
24-inch drum sized for residential lawns and tighter spaces
Time-Saving Convenience
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
Garant’s GPLR24 24-inch push lawn roller is a compact, premium build favored for tight lawns and precision work, offering a sturdier, longer-lasting finish than similarly sized poly rollers. It typically costs more per inch than mass-market poly units but provides better longevity and a corrosion-resistant finish that bridges the gap between inexpensive poly models and full steel machines.
24-inch precision
Fine finish compactor
Agile push control
24-inch drum sized for residential lawns and tighter spaces
Push-only design with ergonomic handle for easy manual control
24-inch precision
Fine finish compactor
Agile push control
24-inch drum sized for residential lawns and tighter spaces
Push-only design with ergonomic handle for easy manual control
$180-300 CAD
Ohio Steel 60T Steel Lawn Roller
Ohio Steel’s 60T steel lawn roller is the market leader for heavy-duty, high-capacity compaction needs, delivering maximum weight and industrial-strength performance for large properties and professional landscaping. It outstrips the other rollers on this list for raw flattening power, though that advantage comes with higher purchase cost, heavier handling requirements, and greater maintenance than poly or smaller steel alternatives.
Industrial strength
Extra-wide drum
Industrial strength
Extra-wide drum
Review Summary
"The Ohio Steel 60T is praised for its heavy-duty steel construction and excellent compaction—popular with users needing commercial-grade results—but many find it very heavy to tow/push and advise regular maintenance to prevent rust. Buyers rate it highly for durability and performance, with trade-offs around weight and upkeep."
Fortress-grade build
All-steel drum and frame with powder-coat finish for durability
Fortress-grade build
All-steel drum and frame with powder-coat finish for durability
Time-Saving Convenience
Increased Safety & Security
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
Ohio Steel’s 60T steel lawn roller is the market leader for heavy-duty, high-capacity compaction needs, delivering maximum weight and industrial-strength performance for large properties and professional landscaping. It outstrips the other rollers on this list for raw flattening power, though that advantage comes with higher purchase cost, heavier handling requirements, and greater maintenance than poly or smaller steel alternatives.
Industrial strength
Extra-wide drum
Fortress-grade build
All-steel drum and frame with powder-coat finish for durability
Versatile mounting/tow options compatible with many mowers and small tractors
Industrial strength
Extra-wide drum
Fortress-grade build
All-steel drum and frame with powder-coat finish for durability
Versatile mounting/tow options compatible with many mowers and small tractors
$200-350 CAD