Coleman Classic Propane Stove
The Coleman Classic Propane Stove earns its place as the value-oriented leader among tabletop propane stoves — reliable, easy to operate, and widely available at a lower price point than the premium Camp Chef and GSI models. While it doesn’t match the Everest 2X in raw BTU output or the Selkirk in cooking area, its straightforward design and low replacement-parts cost make it the smart economical choice for casual campers and backyard use.
Rugged classic
Two-burner power
Rugged classic
Two-burner power
Review Summary
"Longtime users praise its reliable two-burner performance, easy setup and good value, though prolonged use reveals intermittent ignition failures and plastic wear; wind and heat distribution can be uneven."
Diner vibes
Two high-output burners (around 11,000 BTU each) for simultaneous cooking
Diner vibes
Two high-output burners (around 11,000 BTU each) for simultaneous cooking
Time-Saving Convenience
The Coleman Classic Propane Stove earns its place as the value-oriented leader among tabletop propane stoves — reliable, easy to operate, and widely available at a lower price point than the premium Camp Chef and GSI models. While it doesn’t match the Everest 2X in raw BTU output or the Selkirk in cooking area, its straightforward design and low replacement-parts cost make it the smart economical choice for casual campers and backyard use.
Rugged classic
Two-burner power
Diner vibes
Two high-output burners (around 11,000 BTU each) for simultaneous cooking
Push-button ignition and adjustable flame control for easy use
Rugged classic
Two-burner power
Diner vibes
Two high-output burners (around 11,000 BTU each) for simultaneous cooking
Push-button ignition and adjustable flame control for easy use
Camp Chef Everest 2X
The Camp Chef Everest 2X is the market leader for performance-focused tabletop propane cooking, delivering high BTU output, precise simmer control, and dual-burner flexibility that serious outdoor chefs will appreciate. It commands a premium relative to Coleman and Martin, but its superior heat, build quality, and cooking versatility justify the investment for users who need power and control rather than maximum portability.
High-output heat
Precise flame control
High-output heat
Precise flame control
Review Summary
"Owners rave about the Everest 2X's commercial-grade power, precise heat control and sturdy stainless construction that holds up after heavy use; downsides are weight, fuel consumption, and a premium price."
Summit sizzle
High-output burners (approximately 15,000 BTU per burner) for fast boiling and heavy-duty cooking
Summit sizzle
High-output burners (approximately 15,000 BTU per burner) for fast boiling and heavy-duty cooking
Time-Saving Convenience
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
The Camp Chef Everest 2X is the market leader for performance-focused tabletop propane cooking, delivering high BTU output, precise simmer control, and dual-burner flexibility that serious outdoor chefs will appreciate. It commands a premium relative to Coleman and Martin, but its superior heat, build quality, and cooking versatility justify the investment for users who need power and control rather than maximum portability.
High-output heat
Precise flame control
Summit sizzle
High-output burners (approximately 15,000 BTU per burner) for fast boiling and heavy-duty cooking
Heavy-duty construction with cast-iron grates and stainless-steel components for stability and durability
High-output heat
Precise flame control
Summit sizzle
High-output burners (approximately 15,000 BTU per burner) for fast boiling and heavy-duty cooking
Heavy-duty construction with cast-iron grates and stainless-steel components for stability and durability
Eureka Ignite Plus
The Eureka Ignite Plus strikes a balance between portability and capability, offering dependable ignition and a compact footprint that outshines bulkier options like the GSI Selkirk when campsite space is limited. Positioned in the mid-price range, it provides more modern features and better travel-friendliness than the basic Coleman while avoiding the higher cost and weight of the Camp Chef Everest 2X.
Instant ignite
Wind-proof design
Instant ignite
Wind-proof design
Review Summary
"Regular users like the Ignite Plus for its compact size, quick boil times and integrated wind protection, but many report occasional ignition issues and less durable components after repeated trips."
Pocket campfire
Compact single-burner tabletop design ideal for small campsites and limited counter space
Pocket campfire
Compact single-burner tabletop design ideal for small campsites and limited counter space
Time-Saving Convenience
Increased Safety & Security
The Eureka Ignite Plus strikes a balance between portability and capability, offering dependable ignition and a compact footprint that outshines bulkier options like the GSI Selkirk when campsite space is limited. Positioned in the mid-price range, it provides more modern features and better travel-friendliness than the basic Coleman while avoiding the higher cost and weight of the Camp Chef Everest 2X.
Instant ignite
Wind-proof design
Pocket campfire
Compact single-burner tabletop design ideal for small campsites and limited counter space
Piezo ignition with precise flame control that supports simmering and boiling
Instant ignite
Wind-proof design
Pocket campfire
Compact single-burner tabletop design ideal for small campsites and limited counter space
Piezo ignition with precise flame control that supports simmering and boiling
$120-180 CAD
GSI Outdoors Selkirk 540+
The GSI Outdoors Selkirk 540+ sits at the premium end as the best tabletop choice for group cooking, with a wide cooking surface, integrated wind protection, and rugged construction made for family meals and longer outings. Heavier and more costly than the Martin or Eureka models, it compensates by delivering greater capacity and a grill-like experience that outperforms the smaller stoves for multi-person cooking.
Spacious cooktop
Even heat spread
Spacious cooktop
Even heat spread
Review Summary
"Users appreciate the Selkirk 540+'s solid stainless build, even burners and long-term durability for frequent car camping, though it's heavier and more expensive than basic tabletop stoves."
Feast-maker
Two-burner layout providing balanced cooking area and versatile heat distribution
Feast-maker
Two-burner layout providing balanced cooking area and versatile heat distribution
Time-Saving Convenience
The GSI Outdoors Selkirk 540+ sits at the premium end as the best tabletop choice for group cooking, with a wide cooking surface, integrated wind protection, and rugged construction made for family meals and longer outings. Heavier and more costly than the Martin or Eureka models, it compensates by delivering greater capacity and a grill-like experience that outperforms the smaller stoves for multi-person cooking.
Spacious cooktop
Even heat spread
Feast-maker
Two-burner layout providing balanced cooking area and versatile heat distribution
Rugged steel body with full windscreen to maintain consistent flames in breezy conditions
Spacious cooktop
Even heat spread
Feast-maker
Two-burner layout providing balanced cooking area and versatile heat distribution
Rugged steel body with full windscreen to maintain consistent flames in breezy conditions
Martin Portable Propane Stove
The Martin Portable Propane Stove is a compact, budget-friendly option tailored for solo campers and light meal prep, delivering reliable basic performance in a very portable package. Typically the most affordable choice on this list, it trades off some power, cooking area, and advanced features like fine simmer control when compared with the Camp Chef and GSI models, making it ideal for ultralight or infrequent users.
Ultra-portable
Tool-free setup
Ultra-portable
Tool-free setup
Review Summary
"Most buyers find the Martin portable stove adequate and affordable for occasional use, but extended use exposes flimsier build, inconsistent ignition and lower heat output compared with name-brand models."
Picnic show-off
Affordable, lightweight tabletop design that prioritizes portability and simple setup
Picnic show-off
Affordable, lightweight tabletop design that prioritizes portability and simple setup
Time-Saving Convenience
Increased Safety & Security
Aesthetic & Personal Appeal
The Martin Portable Propane Stove is a compact, budget-friendly option tailored for solo campers and light meal prep, delivering reliable basic performance in a very portable package. Typically the most affordable choice on this list, it trades off some power, cooking area, and advanced features like fine simmer control when compared with the Camp Chef and GSI models, making it ideal for ultralight or infrequent users.
Ultra-portable
Tool-free setup
Picnic show-off
Affordable, lightweight tabletop design that prioritizes portability and simple setup
Manual ignition with adjustable heat control suitable for basic campsite cooking
Ultra-portable
Tool-free setup
Picnic show-off
Affordable, lightweight tabletop design that prioritizes portability and simple setup
Manual ignition with adjustable heat control suitable for basic campsite cooking