Kidde 900-0102-02 Nighthawk Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm
A best-in-class mid-range unit for combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms that balances reliable sensing with an affordable price point; its proven smoke and CO detection chemistry and simple installation make it a popular choice for mainstream households. Compared with the Nest Protect it forgoes smart-home features but delivers comparable life-safety performance at a lower cost, and it offers more on-device functionality than basic battery-only options like the KN-COSM-BA.
Compact night-guard
Single-button ease
Compact night-guard
Single-button ease
Review Summary
"Most long-term users praise the Kidde Nighthawk for reliable smoke and CO detection, loud alerts and straightforward installation; a minority report occasional false alarms and sensitivity with the test/reset button."
Loud and proud beep
AC-powered with battery backup for continuous protection during outages
Loud and proud beep
AC-powered with battery backup for continuous protection during outages
Increased Safety & Security
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
Time-Saving Convenience
A best-in-class mid-range unit for combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms that balances reliable sensing with an affordable price point; its proven smoke and CO detection chemistry and simple installation make it a popular choice for mainstream households. Compared with the Nest Protect it forgoes smart-home features but delivers comparable life-safety performance at a lower cost, and it offers more on-device functionality than basic battery-only options like the KN-COSM-BA.
Compact night-guard
Single-button ease
Loud and proud beep
AC-powered with battery backup for continuous protection during outages
Combination smoke and electrochemical CO sensing in a single unit
Compact night-guard
Single-button ease
Loud and proud beep
AC-powered with battery backup for continuous protection during outages
Combination smoke and electrochemical CO sensing in a single unit
First Alert SCO5CN Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Detector
A budget-friendly combination smoke and carbon monoxide detector that focuses on core protection and low upfront cost, making it attractive for renters and secondary rooms. It lacks the advanced connectivity of the Nest Protect and the whole-house interconnect of the BRK SC9120B, but its lower purchase and maintenance costs make it a practical alternative to higher-priced or hardwired solutions.
Clear voice alerts
Tool-free setup
Clear voice alerts
Tool-free setup
Review Summary
"Buyers like the First Alert SCO5CN for its low price and simple setup, but many long-term users report nuisance chirps, occasional false alarms and concerns about durability over several years."
Friendly voice chime
Battery-operated design for flexible placement without wiring
Friendly voice chime
Battery-operated design for flexible placement without wiring
Increased Safety & Security
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
Time-Saving Convenience
A budget-friendly combination smoke and carbon monoxide detector that focuses on core protection and low upfront cost, making it attractive for renters and secondary rooms. It lacks the advanced connectivity of the Nest Protect and the whole-house interconnect of the BRK SC9120B, but its lower purchase and maintenance costs make it a practical alternative to higher-priced or hardwired solutions.
Clear voice alerts
Tool-free setup
Friendly voice chime
Battery-operated design for flexible placement without wiring
Combines smoke detection with an electrochemical CO sensor
Clear voice alerts
Tool-free setup
Friendly voice chime
Battery-operated design for flexible placement without wiring
Combines smoke detection with an electrochemical CO sensor
$35-60 CAD
Nest Protect 2nd Generation Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm
The market leader for smart combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms, Nest Protect combines advanced split-spectrum smoke sensing and electrochemical CO detection with smartphone alerts, self-tests and home automation integration—ideal for tech-forward homes. Although it carries a premium price versus Kidde and First Alert models, its remote notifications and diagnostic data can reduce false alarms and maintenance time, delivering long-term convenience and potential cost savings for connected households.
App push alerts
Auto self-tests
App push alerts
Auto self-tests
Review Summary
"Owners consistently praise the Nest Protect (2nd Gen) for accurate sensors, clear voice alerts, smart notifications and reliable self-testing over time; criticisms focus on higher cost and occasional connectivity or isolated false-alarm reports."
Polite voice guidance
Wi-Fi connected with app notifications and remote alerts
Polite voice guidance
Wi-Fi connected with app notifications and remote alerts
Tech-Savvy Living
Increased Safety & Security
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
The market leader for smart combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms, Nest Protect combines advanced split-spectrum smoke sensing and electrochemical CO detection with smartphone alerts, self-tests and home automation integration—ideal for tech-forward homes. Although it carries a premium price versus Kidde and First Alert models, its remote notifications and diagnostic data can reduce false alarms and maintenance time, delivering long-term convenience and potential cost savings for connected households.
App push alerts
Auto self-tests
Polite voice guidance
Wi-Fi connected with app notifications and remote alerts
Split-spectrum smoke sensing plus electrochemical CO detection
App push alerts
Auto self-tests
Polite voice guidance
Wi-Fi connected with app notifications and remote alerts
Split-spectrum smoke sensing plus electrochemical CO detection
Kidde KN-COSM-BA Battery Operated Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm
A flexible battery-operated combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarm well suited for retrofits and locations without wiring, offering dependable detection and straightforward upkeep at a competitive price. It sacrifices interconnect and smart features found in the BRK SC9120B and Nest Protect, but its portability and low installation cost make it a cost-effective choice compared with hardwired or app-enabled models.
Battery marathoner
Slim profile
Battery marathoner
Slim profile
Review Summary
"Users generally find the Kidde KN-COSM-BA dependable and easy to install with clear alarms, though some report premature battery drain, intermittent chirping or rare false alarms after extended use."
Hush-button hero
Battery-operated for straightforward installation and placement
Hush-button hero
Battery-operated for straightforward installation and placement
Increased Safety & Security
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
Time-Saving Convenience
A flexible battery-operated combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarm well suited for retrofits and locations without wiring, offering dependable detection and straightforward upkeep at a competitive price. It sacrifices interconnect and smart features found in the BRK SC9120B and Nest Protect, but its portability and low installation cost make it a cost-effective choice compared with hardwired or app-enabled models.
Battery marathoner
Slim profile
Hush-button hero
Battery-operated for straightforward installation and placement
Integrated smoke detection and CO sensing in one compact unit
Battery marathoner
Slim profile
Hush-button hero
Battery-operated for straightforward installation and placement
Integrated smoke detection and CO sensing in one compact unit
First Alert BRK SC9120B Hardwired Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm
A hardwired combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarm designed for whole-house protection with interconnect capability, making it preferable where code compliance and networked alerts are required. While it does not provide Nest-level smart features, its reliability and centralized installation often yield better cost-efficiency for builders and large homes compared with deploying multiple standalone battery units.
Hardwired backbone
Interconnect ready
Hardwired backbone
Interconnect ready
Review Summary
"Long-term owners appreciate the First Alert BRK SC9120B's hardwired reliability, battery backup and loud alerts, while some note occasional interconnect or wiring compatibility issues and sporadic nuisance alarms."
Steady guardian hum
Hardwired 120V installation with battery backup for reliable power
Steady guardian hum
Hardwired 120V installation with battery backup for reliable power
Increased Safety & Security
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
Time-Saving Convenience
A hardwired combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarm designed for whole-house protection with interconnect capability, making it preferable where code compliance and networked alerts are required. While it does not provide Nest-level smart features, its reliability and centralized installation often yield better cost-efficiency for builders and large homes compared with deploying multiple standalone battery units.
Hardwired backbone
Interconnect ready
Steady guardian hum
Hardwired 120V installation with battery backup for reliable power
Interconnect-capable to link multiple alarms in a home
Hardwired backbone
Interconnect ready
Steady guardian hum
Hardwired 120V installation with battery backup for reliable power
Interconnect-capable to link multiple alarms in a home