Irwin Bolt-Grip 5-Piece Bolt Extractor Set
The Irwin Bolt-Grip 5-Piece Bolt Extractor Set earns a best-in-class spot for its aggressive flute geometry and hardened steel construction that reliably bites into rounded or damaged bolts, making it a top choice for professional mechanics and tradespeople. Compared with the other kits on this list, Irwin balances precision engineering and wide availability — it typically commands a mid-to-premium price but saves labor time on stubborn fasteners, reducing overall job cost versus cheaper, less effective alternatives.
Aggressive bite
Five-piece range
Aggressive bite
Five-piece range
Review Summary
"Users praise the Irwin Bolt-Grip 5-piece set for reliably removing rounded and stuck bolts with minimal slipping, and report long-term durability when used properly. A few note it struggles with extremely corroded or hardened fasteners but overall is considered a go-to extractor set."
Bites like a shark
Spiral-fluted, tapered design bites into rounded or rusted bolts for reliable extraction.
Bites like a shark
Spiral-fluted, tapered design bites into rounded or rusted bolts for reliable extraction.
Time-Saving Convenience
Optimized Work Efficiency
The Irwin Bolt-Grip 5-Piece Bolt Extractor Set earns a best-in-class spot for its aggressive flute geometry and hardened steel construction that reliably bites into rounded or damaged bolts, making it a top choice for professional mechanics and tradespeople. Compared with the other kits on this list, Irwin balances precision engineering and wide availability — it typically commands a mid-to-premium price but saves labor time on stubborn fasteners, reducing overall job cost versus cheaper, less effective alternatives.
Aggressive bite
Five-piece range
Bites like a shark
Spiral-fluted, tapered design bites into rounded or rusted bolts for reliable extraction.
Heat-treated steel construction works with standard sockets and impacts for high torque removal.
Aggressive bite
Five-piece range
Bites like a shark
Spiral-fluted, tapered design bites into rounded or rusted bolts for reliable extraction.
Heat-treated steel construction works with standard sockets and impacts for high torque removal.
Ridgid Screw Extractor Set
The Ridgid Screw Extractor Set stands out as a market leader for heavy-duty applications thanks to its reputation for durability and a trades-oriented warranty and support network, making it a dependable option on worksites. Technically robust and often competitively priced against premium brands like Irwin, Ridgid trades a fraction of the bite geometry specialization for ruggedness and warranty-backed value, which appeals to users who prioritize lifetime tool reliability over minimal gains in extraction aggressiveness.
Forged tough
Left-hand pull
Forged tough
Left-hand pull
Review Summary
"The Ridgid screw extractor set is seen as a solid, professional-grade option that performs well on a wide range of seized screws and bolts, with reviewers appreciating the hardened construction. Some users mention occasional breakage when used incorrectly or on very large frozen fasteners, but overall feedback is positive."
Claws stripped screws
Left-hand spiral extractors grip broken or seized screws and drive them out as the drill reverses.
Claws stripped screws
Left-hand spiral extractors grip broken or seized screws and drive them out as the drill reverses.
Time-Saving Convenience
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
Skill Development & Mastery
The Ridgid Screw Extractor Set stands out as a market leader for heavy-duty applications thanks to its reputation for durability and a trades-oriented warranty and support network, making it a dependable option on worksites. Technically robust and often competitively priced against premium brands like Irwin, Ridgid trades a fraction of the bite geometry specialization for ruggedness and warranty-backed value, which appeals to users who prioritize lifetime tool reliability over minimal gains in extraction aggressiveness.
Forged tough
Left-hand pull
Claws stripped screws
Left-hand spiral extractors grip broken or seized screws and drive them out as the drill reverses.
Hardened steel construction built to withstand high torque from drills and impact drivers.
Forged tough
Left-hand pull
Claws stripped screws
Left-hand spiral extractors grip broken or seized screws and drive them out as the drill reverses.
Hardened steel construction built to withstand high torque from drills and impact drivers.
Mastercraft Maximum Impact Bolt Extractor Set
The Mastercraft Maximum Impact Bolt Extractor Set is positioned as a cost-effective, impact-rated alternative that delivers solid extraction performance for DIYers and light commercial users without the premium cost of top-tier brands. Compared to Irwin and Ridgid, Mastercraft Maximum offers better bang-for-buck in Canadian markets—its heat-treated, impact-ready parts let users use an impact wrench for quicker removals, though it may not match the refined bite or warranty support of the market leaders.
Impact-ready
Broad size spread
Impact-ready
Broad size spread
Review Summary
"Mastercraft Maximum extractors are viewed as a good budget choice that work adequately for light-to-moderate stuck fasteners, though several users report shorter life and occasional fitment issues compared with premium brands. Many buyers find them acceptable for occasional DIY use but not heavy professional work."
Built like a tank
Designed for impact use with heavy-duty, heat-treated steel for demanding extraction jobs.
Built like a tank
Designed for impact use with heavy-duty, heat-treated steel for demanding extraction jobs.
Time-Saving Convenience
Optimized Work Efficiency
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
The Mastercraft Maximum Impact Bolt Extractor Set is positioned as a cost-effective, impact-rated alternative that delivers solid extraction performance for DIYers and light commercial users without the premium cost of top-tier brands. Compared to Irwin and Ridgid, Mastercraft Maximum offers better bang-for-buck in Canadian markets—its heat-treated, impact-ready parts let users use an impact wrench for quicker removals, though it may not match the refined bite or warranty support of the market leaders.
Impact-ready
Broad size spread
Built like a tank
Designed for impact use with heavy-duty, heat-treated steel for demanding extraction jobs.
Tapered, aggressive flutes bite into rounded or corroded nuts, bolts, and studs.
Impact-ready
Broad size spread
Built like a tank
Designed for impact use with heavy-duty, heat-treated steel for demanding extraction jobs.
Tapered, aggressive flutes bite into rounded or corroded nuts, bolts, and studs.
$40-90 CAD
DeWalt DW2298 Square Recess Power Bit Set
The DeWalt DW2298 Square Recess Power Bit Set is included as a prevention- and removal-focused tool: high-quality square-recess bits reduce cam-out and make it easier to remove square-headed fasteners or prevent stripping in the first place. While not a bolt-extractor set per se, DeWalt’s hardened, precision-ground bits are a professional-grade investment that can lower extraction needs and labor time compared with relying solely on extractors; they carry a higher upfront cost but often extend bit life and reduce fastener damage on jobs.
Precision fit
Power-rated bits
Precision fit
Power-rated bits
Review Summary
"The DeWalt DW2298 square recess power bit set is widely rated for excellent durability and consistent fit in Robertson-style screws, with users noting long life under regular use. Reviewers consistently praise build quality and value, making it a favorite among pros and serious DIYers."
Locks onto screws
Precision square-recess (Robertson) bits reduce cam-out and ensure consistent engagement.
Locks onto screws
Precision square-recess (Robertson) bits reduce cam-out and ensure consistent engagement.
Optimized Work Efficiency
Time-Saving Convenience
Skill Development & Mastery
The DeWalt DW2298 Square Recess Power Bit Set is included as a prevention- and removal-focused tool: high-quality square-recess bits reduce cam-out and make it easier to remove square-headed fasteners or prevent stripping in the first place. While not a bolt-extractor set per se, DeWalt’s hardened, precision-ground bits are a professional-grade investment that can lower extraction needs and labor time compared with relying solely on extractors; they carry a higher upfront cost but often extend bit life and reduce fastener damage on jobs.
Precision fit
Power-rated bits
Locks onto screws
Precision square-recess (Robertson) bits reduce cam-out and ensure consistent engagement.
Heat-treated, impact-rated bits suitable for high-torque drivers and repetitive use.
Precision fit
Power-rated bits
Locks onto screws
Precision square-recess (Robertson) bits reduce cam-out and ensure consistent engagement.
Heat-treated, impact-rated bits suitable for high-torque drivers and repetitive use.
Princess Auto PowerFist Damaged Screw Extractor Kit
The PowerFist Damaged Screw Extractor Kit from Princess Auto is the budget-friendly option tailored to occasional users and DIYers who need a complete kit without breaking the bank. Financially attractive in Canadian markets, it provides a broad assortment that covers most household and shop scenarios; however, it sacrifices some of the hardened metallurgy and precision fit of Irwin, Ridgid, or DeWalt products, so it’s best for lighter-duty or infrequent fastener-removal tasks.
Budget-friendly
Versatile sizes
Budget-friendly
Versatile sizes
Review Summary
"Princess Auto PowerFist damaged screw extractor kits are regarded as a low-cost option that can work in many cases, but reviews are mixed due to variable durability and occasional broken pieces when used on very stubborn fasteners. Buyers often recommend as a spare or occasional-use kit rather than a professional mainstay."
Rescues stuck screws
PowerFist kit includes stepped extractors and pilot drills to remove stripped or damaged screws.
Rescues stuck screws
PowerFist kit includes stepped extractors and pilot drills to remove stripped or damaged screws.
Time-Saving Convenience
Reduced Stress & Anxiety
The PowerFist Damaged Screw Extractor Kit from Princess Auto is the budget-friendly option tailored to occasional users and DIYers who need a complete kit without breaking the bank. Financially attractive in Canadian markets, it provides a broad assortment that covers most household and shop scenarios; however, it sacrifices some of the hardened metallurgy and precision fit of Irwin, Ridgid, or DeWalt products, so it’s best for lighter-duty or infrequent fastener-removal tasks.
Budget-friendly
Versatile sizes
Rescues stuck screws
PowerFist kit includes stepped extractors and pilot drills to remove stripped or damaged screws.
Durable forged extractors designed to bite into compromised screw heads under load.
Budget-friendly
Versatile sizes
Rescues stuck screws
PowerFist kit includes stepped extractors and pilot drills to remove stripped or damaged screws.
Durable forged extractors designed to bite into compromised screw heads under load.
$25-60 CAD