Open Farm Wild-Caught Salmon Recipe
Open Farm's Wild-Caught Salmon Recipe earns a best-in-class spot for owners who prioritize transparent, responsibly sourced fish ingredients and full-traceability—its sustainability and welfare commitments align well with shoppers seeking organic or ethically produced fish-based diets. Compared with the higher-protein, multi-fish offerings in this list, Open Farm trades some of Orijen and Acana's raw-protein intensity for clearer sourcing credentials and a competitive mid-to-premium price point.
Wild-caught protein
Limited ingredients
Wild-caught protein
Limited ingredients
Review Summary
"Users praise the ethically sourced, high-quality ingredients and good palatability, with many noting improved coat and overall condition. Common complaints are the premium price and occasional digestive upset in very sensitive cats."
Ocean-kissed flavor
Uses wild-caught salmon with traceable, sustainably sourced seafood.
Ocean-kissed flavor
Uses wild-caught salmon with traceable, sustainably sourced seafood.
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
Open Farm's Wild-Caught Salmon Recipe earns a best-in-class spot for owners who prioritize transparent, responsibly sourced fish ingredients and full-traceability—its sustainability and welfare commitments align well with shoppers seeking organic or ethically produced fish-based diets. Compared with the higher-protein, multi-fish offerings in this list, Open Farm trades some of Orijen and Acana's raw-protein intensity for clearer sourcing credentials and a competitive mid-to-premium price point.
Wild-caught protein
Limited ingredients
Ocean-kissed flavor
Uses wild-caught salmon with traceable, sustainably sourced seafood.
Grain-free recipe with high-quality animal proteins and limited fillers.
Wild-caught protein
Limited ingredients
Ocean-kissed flavor
Uses wild-caught salmon with traceable, sustainably sourced seafood.
Grain-free recipe with high-quality animal proteins and limited fillers.
Orijen Six Fish Cat Food
Orijen Six Fish is a market leader for nutrient-dense, biologically appropriate diets, delivering very high inclusions of fresh and raw fish from six species which gives it a technical advantage in amino acid and omega profiles. While typically at the top price tier, it outperforms others like Acana and FirstMate on sheer variety and protein density, making it the pick for owners prioritizing maximum fish-derived nutrition over strict organic labeling.
Six-fish variety
High protein punch
Six-fish variety
High protein punch
Review Summary
"Long-term owners report excellent protein quality and a strong fish flavor that most cats love, often citing visible health improvements. Downsides mentioned are a potent smell and a high cost compared with mainstream brands."
Sea symphony taste
Biologically appropriate formula featuring multiple whole fish species for varied protein.
Sea symphony taste
Biologically appropriate formula featuring multiple whole fish species for varied protein.
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
Orijen Six Fish is a market leader for nutrient-dense, biologically appropriate diets, delivering very high inclusions of fresh and raw fish from six species which gives it a technical advantage in amino acid and omega profiles. While typically at the top price tier, it outperforms others like Acana and FirstMate on sheer variety and protein density, making it the pick for owners prioritizing maximum fish-derived nutrition over strict organic labeling.
Six-fish variety
High protein punch
Sea symphony taste
Biologically appropriate formula featuring multiple whole fish species for varied protein.
Very high protein and rich in marine omega-3s to support overall health.
Six-fish variety
High protein punch
Sea symphony taste
Biologically appropriate formula featuring multiple whole fish species for varied protein.
Very high protein and rich in marine omega-3s to support overall health.
FirstMate Wild Pacific Salmon Formula
FirstMate Wild Pacific Salmon Formula stands out as a best-in-class single-protein, small-batch option that emphasizes locally sourced wild Pacific salmon and a clean, limited-ingredient profile—ideal for cats with sensitivities. It offers a cost-effective alternative to multi-fish premium formulas by concentrating on one high-quality fish source, delivering strong omega-3 benefits without the highest multi-species price premium.
Wild Pacific salmon
Simple single-protein
Wild Pacific salmon
Simple single-protein
Review Summary
"Owners of sensitive or senior cats appreciate the simple, fish-forward recipe and often see better digestion and coat condition over time. Some users note limited availability and a higher price per pound."
Northwest ocean zing
Primary protein from wild Pacific salmon sourced and produced in Canada.
Northwest ocean zing
Primary protein from wild Pacific salmon sourced and produced in Canada.
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
FirstMate Wild Pacific Salmon Formula stands out as a best-in-class single-protein, small-batch option that emphasizes locally sourced wild Pacific salmon and a clean, limited-ingredient profile—ideal for cats with sensitivities. It offers a cost-effective alternative to multi-fish premium formulas by concentrating on one high-quality fish source, delivering strong omega-3 benefits without the highest multi-species price premium.
Wild Pacific salmon
Simple single-protein
Northwest ocean zing
Primary protein from wild Pacific salmon sourced and produced in Canada.
Limited-ingredient, low-carbohydrate formula suited for sensitive digestion.
Wild Pacific salmon
Simple single-protein
Northwest ocean zing
Primary protein from wild Pacific salmon sourced and produced in Canada.
Limited-ingredient, low-carbohydrate formula suited for sensitive digestion.
Go! Solutions Skin + Coat Care Salmon Recipe
Go! Solutions Skin + Coat Care Salmon Recipe is a purpose-built formula that pairs salmon-rich protein with targeted skin and coat supports, such as added omega fatty acids and specific micronutrients, making it the best choice for cats with dermatological or coat concerns. Technically it is more specialized than broader diet-focused lines like Orijen or Acana, and it typically sits at a mid-tier price point, offering focused benefits without the top-tier cost.
Omega-rich boost
Coat-loving omegas
Omega-rich boost
Coat-loving omegas
Review Summary
"Buyers commonly report improvements in skin and coat health thanks to the omega-rich formula, and many cats accept it readily. A subset of cats reject the taste or show no measurable benefit, and some shoppers question the value versus price."
Fur-flaunt flavor
Formulated to support skin and coat health with concentrated omega-3 and omega-6 nutrients.
Fur-flaunt flavor
Formulated to support skin and coat health with concentrated omega-3 and omega-6 nutrients.
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
Go! Solutions Skin + Coat Care Salmon Recipe is a purpose-built formula that pairs salmon-rich protein with targeted skin and coat supports, such as added omega fatty acids and specific micronutrients, making it the best choice for cats with dermatological or coat concerns. Technically it is more specialized than broader diet-focused lines like Orijen or Acana, and it typically sits at a mid-tier price point, offering focused benefits without the top-tier cost.
Omega-rich boost
Coat-loving omegas
Fur-flaunt flavor
Formulated to support skin and coat health with concentrated omega-3 and omega-6 nutrients.
Salmon is the main animal protein and is paired with added nutrients like biotin and zinc.
Omega-rich boost
Coat-loving omegas
Fur-flaunt flavor
Formulated to support skin and coat health with concentrated omega-3 and omega-6 nutrients.
Salmon is the main animal protein and is paired with added nutrients like biotin and zinc.
Acana Pacifica Cat Food
Acana Pacifica earns its market-leader position by balancing high inclusions of multiple Pacific fish species with a more affordable price point than ultra-premium options, delivering strong technical value for owners seeking varied fish nutrition. Compared to single-source FirstMate or transparency-focused Open Farm, Acana provides breadth—multiple fish proteins and regional sourcing—making it a pragmatic choice for those wanting diverse fish-based nutrition on a moderately premium budget.
High fish ratio
Whole-prey style
High fish ratio
Whole-prey style
Review Summary
"Well-liked for its high-quality fish ingredients and balanced nutrition, with many owners noting good energy and coat condition in their cats. A minority report occasional rancidity concerns and consider it a premium-priced option."
Pacific party taste
Features a mix of wild-caught Pacific fish to provide diverse proteins and nutrients.
Pacific party taste
Features a mix of wild-caught Pacific fish to provide diverse proteins and nutrients.
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
Acana Pacifica earns its market-leader position by balancing high inclusions of multiple Pacific fish species with a more affordable price point than ultra-premium options, delivering strong technical value for owners seeking varied fish nutrition. Compared to single-source FirstMate or transparency-focused Open Farm, Acana provides breadth—multiple fish proteins and regional sourcing—making it a pragmatic choice for those wanting diverse fish-based nutrition on a moderately premium budget.
High fish ratio
Whole-prey style
Pacific party taste
Features a mix of wild-caught Pacific fish to provide diverse proteins and nutrients.
High-protein, low-carb formula using regional ingredients and the brand's WholePrey approach.
High fish ratio
Whole-prey style
Pacific party taste
Features a mix of wild-caught Pacific fish to provide diverse proteins and nutrients.
High-protein, low-carb formula using regional ingredients and the brand's WholePrey approach.