West Paw Zogoflex Echo Zisc
The Zogoflex Echo Zisc is positioned as best-in-class for recycled silicone gentle dog toys thanks to its exceptional bounce, soft edge profile, and West Paw’s strong product guarantee. Compared with the other toys on this list it commands a higher upfront price but delivers superior longevity and a lower lifetime cost per play due to durable, non-toxic recycled silicone and a warranty that outperforms budget alternatives.
Gentle on gums
Floats on water
Gentle on gums
Floats on water
Review Summary
"Users consistently praise the Echo Zisc for its floatability, gentle feel on dogs' mouths, and long-lasting bounce; a minority note it isn't indestructible for heavy chewers. Overall buyers say it’s a reliable, dog-friendly frisbee for fetch and water play."
Throws like a UFO
Made from Zogoflex® recyclable material that balances durability with gentle flex for dogs' teeth.
Throws like a UFO
Made from Zogoflex® recyclable material that balances durability with gentle flex for dogs' teeth.
Recreational Enjoyment
Increased Safety & Security
The Zogoflex Echo Zisc is positioned as best-in-class for recycled silicone gentle dog toys thanks to its exceptional bounce, soft edge profile, and West Paw’s strong product guarantee. Compared with the other toys on this list it commands a higher upfront price but delivers superior longevity and a lower lifetime cost per play due to durable, non-toxic recycled silicone and a warranty that outperforms budget alternatives.
Gentle on gums
Floats on water
Throws like a UFO
Made from Zogoflex® recyclable material that balances durability with gentle flex for dogs' teeth.
Lightweight and buoyant — great for water fetch and long-distance throws without hard impact.
Gentle on gums
Floats on water
Throws like a UFO
Made from Zogoflex® recyclable material that balances durability with gentle flex for dogs' teeth.
Lightweight and buoyant — great for water fetch and long-distance throws without hard impact.
$25-40 CAD
West Paw Zogoflex Echo Bone
The Zogoflex Echo Bone combines the same recycled silicone formulation as the Zisc with a chew-friendly shape and reinforced stress points, earning it a market-leader status for gentle chewers. Technically it balances resilience and softness better than many cheaper options, offering better value over time than single-use or more rigid toys while remaining gentler on teeth than harder rubber competitors.
Soft chew surface
Durable bendy material
Soft chew surface
Durable bendy material
Review Summary
"Buyers like the Zogoflex Echo Bone for its soft-but-durable material, buoyancy, and safety for teeth, though a few strong chewers have reported chewing through over time. Most owners find it worth the price for interactive play and fetching."
Chew like a boss
Zogoflex® construction provides resilient yet flexible play that’s kinder to teeth than rigid plastics.
Chew like a boss
Zogoflex® construction provides resilient yet flexible play that’s kinder to teeth than rigid plastics.
Recreational Enjoyment
Skill Development & Mastery
The Zogoflex Echo Bone combines the same recycled silicone formulation as the Zisc with a chew-friendly shape and reinforced stress points, earning it a market-leader status for gentle chewers. Technically it balances resilience and softness better than many cheaper options, offering better value over time than single-use or more rigid toys while remaining gentler on teeth than harder rubber competitors.
Soft chew surface
Durable bendy material
Chew like a boss
Zogoflex® construction provides resilient yet flexible play that’s kinder to teeth than rigid plastics.
Floatable and tough for fetch sessions while remaining recyclable through West Paw’s take-back options.
Soft chew surface
Durable bendy material
Chew like a boss
Zogoflex® construction provides resilient yet flexible play that’s kinder to teeth than rigid plastics.
Floatable and tough for fetch sessions while remaining recyclable through West Paw’s take-back options.
$25-45 CAD
Cycle Dog Ecolast Ball
The Ecolast Ball stands out as a cost-effective, eco-forward option in recycled silicone gentle dog toys, offering a soft, pliable feel and strong puncture resistance at a mid-range price. Compared to premium West Paw pieces it sacrifices some warranty and extreme longevity but wins on price-per-unit and accessibility, making it a smart choice for owners who want recycled-material performance without the premium tag.
Upcycled material
Gentle bouncy feel
Upcycled material
Gentle bouncy feel
Review Summary
"The Cycle Dog Ecolast Ball is applauded for its eco-friendly recycled material, toughness relative to other balls, and good bounce; some users mention a rubbery odor at first and occasional size/weight complaints. Overall reviewers consider it a solid, sustainable play option for average chewers."
Bounces with mischief
Built from Cycle Dog’s Ecolast eco-material designed for lower environmental impact and gentle play.
Bounces with mischief
Built from Cycle Dog’s Ecolast eco-material designed for lower environmental impact and gentle play.
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
The Ecolast Ball stands out as a cost-effective, eco-forward option in recycled silicone gentle dog toys, offering a soft, pliable feel and strong puncture resistance at a mid-range price. Compared to premium West Paw pieces it sacrifices some warranty and extreme longevity but wins on price-per-unit and accessibility, making it a smart choice for owners who want recycled-material performance without the premium tag.
Upcycled material
Gentle bouncy feel
Bounces with mischief
Built from Cycle Dog’s Ecolast eco-material designed for lower environmental impact and gentle play.
Soft, slightly squishy texture protects teeth and gums while still offering bounce and float.
Upcycled material
Gentle bouncy feel
Bounces with mischief
Built from Cycle Dog’s Ecolast eco-material designed for lower environmental impact and gentle play.
Soft, slightly squishy texture protects teeth and gums while still offering bounce and float.
$10-20 CAD
Earth Rated Fetch Toy
Earth Rated’s Fetch Toy is tailored for budget-conscious buyers seeking an eco-friendly, gentle silicone fetch option that’s soft on mouths and packaged sustainably. While not as heavy-duty as the West Paw models, it undercuts competitors on price and offers compelling eco-packaging and accessibility, making it a practical everyday toy for puppies and light chewers.
Soft silicone touch
Eco-friendly build
Soft silicone touch
Eco-friendly build
Review Summary
"Customers report the Earth Rated Fetch Toy is soft on jaws, easy to clean, and well-liked for casual play, but a number of reviews caution it won’t stand up to aggressive chewers. Most users appreciate its gentle design and value as a safe fetch toy."
Green fetch vibes
Soft, pliable construction aims to reduce tooth stress compared with rigid chew toys.
Green fetch vibes
Soft, pliable construction aims to reduce tooth stress compared with rigid chew toys.
Recreational Enjoyment
Earth Rated’s Fetch Toy is tailored for budget-conscious buyers seeking an eco-friendly, gentle silicone fetch option that’s soft on mouths and packaged sustainably. While not as heavy-duty as the West Paw models, it undercuts competitors on price and offers compelling eco-packaging and accessibility, making it a practical everyday toy for puppies and light chewers.
Soft silicone touch
Eco-friendly build
Green fetch vibes
Soft, pliable construction aims to reduce tooth stress compared with rigid chew toys.
Lightweight and buoyant for safe water play, suitable for dogs that need gentler surfaces.
Soft silicone touch
Eco-friendly build
Green fetch vibes
Soft, pliable construction aims to reduce tooth stress compared with rigid chew toys.
Lightweight and buoyant for safe water play, suitable for dogs that need gentler surfaces.
$12-25 CAD
BeOneBreed Silicone Treat Ball
The BeOneBreed Silicone Treat Ball differentiates itself by combining recycled silicone construction with an interactive treat-dispensing design that extends engagement and reduces the need to buy multiple toys. Financially it can save owners money on enrichment by doubling as both a chew and puzzle toy, and technically it offers softer edges than many treat-dispensing plastics, making it gentler for sensitive mouths compared with firmer alternatives on this list.
Treat-dispensing fun
Food-grade silicone
Treat-dispensing fun
Food-grade silicone
Review Summary
"The BeOneBreed silicone treat ball earns high marks for durable, food-grade silicone construction, easy cleaning, and effective slow-dispense treat play; a few buyers note the dispense holes may be too small for larger treats. Overall users are very satisfied with its safety and longevity."
Puzzle for pooches
100% food-grade silicone that’s flexible, gentle on teeth, and free from BPA and phthalates.
Puzzle for pooches
100% food-grade silicone that’s flexible, gentle on teeth, and free from BPA and phthalates.
Recreational Enjoyment
Skill Development & Mastery
Time-Saving Convenience
The BeOneBreed Silicone Treat Ball differentiates itself by combining recycled silicone construction with an interactive treat-dispensing design that extends engagement and reduces the need to buy multiple toys. Financially it can save owners money on enrichment by doubling as both a chew and puzzle toy, and technically it offers softer edges than many treat-dispensing plastics, making it gentler for sensitive mouths compared with firmer alternatives on this list.
Treat-dispensing fun
Food-grade silicone
Puzzle for pooches
100% food-grade silicone that’s flexible, gentle on teeth, and free from BPA and phthalates.
Hollow treat-dispensing design provides mental stimulation while staying easy to clean (dishwasher-safe).
Treat-dispensing fun
Food-grade silicone
Puzzle for pooches
100% food-grade silicone that’s flexible, gentle on teeth, and free from BPA and phthalates.
Hollow treat-dispensing design provides mental stimulation while staying easy to clean (dishwasher-safe).
$15-30 CAD