Coleman Northstar Propane Lantern
The Coleman Northstar Propane Lantern earns its place as a market leader for fuel-and-gas lanterns by delivering very bright, stable light and simple propane-canister operation suitable for car camping and large campsites. It outshines minimalist options like the GSI candle lantern on raw lumen output and is more plug-and-play and lower-maintenance than classic liquid-fuel models such as Coleman's dual-fuel lantern, while offering more immediate convenience than battery-first alternatives like the BioLite AlpenGlow 500.
Sun-bright beam
Quick push-start
Sun-bright beam
Quick push-start
Review Summary
"Routinely praised for bright, reliable illumination and rugged build that stands up to heavy use, though users note mantles can be fragile and it is heavier and less fuel-efficient than modern LEDs."
Rugged camp-ready
Runs on standard 16.4 oz propane cylinders for convenient refills
Rugged camp-ready
Runs on standard 16.4 oz propane cylinders for convenient refills
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
The Coleman Northstar Propane Lantern earns its place as a market leader for fuel-and-gas lanterns by delivering very bright, stable light and simple propane-canister operation suitable for car camping and large campsites. It outshines minimalist options like the GSI candle lantern on raw lumen output and is more plug-and-play and lower-maintenance than classic liquid-fuel models such as Coleman's dual-fuel lantern, while offering more immediate convenience than battery-first alternatives like the BioLite AlpenGlow 500.
Sun-bright beam
Quick push-start
Rugged camp-ready
Runs on standard 16.4 oz propane cylinders for convenient refills
High-output mantle design delivers bright, reliable light for large campsites
Sun-bright beam
Quick push-start
Rugged camp-ready
Runs on standard 16.4 oz propane cylinders for convenient refills
High-output mantle design delivers bright, reliable light for large campsites
BioLite AlpenGlow 500 Lantern
The BioLite AlpenGlow 500 stands out in the fuel-and-gas category by offering a fuel-free, rechargeable 500-lumen lantern that eliminates ongoing fuel costs and emissions while still serving many campsite lighting needs. Compared with gas-burning models on this list it trades top-end throw and extended runtime for lower lifetime operating cost and safer, indoor-capable use, making it a technically modern alternative to fuel-based lanterns for users prioritizing convenience and long-term value.
Mood-color glow
USB powerbank
Mood-color glow
USB powerbank
Review Summary
"Users love its versatile, rechargeable LED output, adjustable color/warmth and long battery life; some long-term owners mention the premium price and occasional durability or connectivity issues."
Cordless warm-tone
USB-C rechargeable internal battery with long runtime and no fuel required
Cordless warm-tone
USB-C rechargeable internal battery with long runtime and no fuel required
Recreational Enjoyment
Eco-Friendly Living
The BioLite AlpenGlow 500 stands out in the fuel-and-gas category by offering a fuel-free, rechargeable 500-lumen lantern that eliminates ongoing fuel costs and emissions while still serving many campsite lighting needs. Compared with gas-burning models on this list it trades top-end throw and extended runtime for lower lifetime operating cost and safer, indoor-capable use, making it a technically modern alternative to fuel-based lanterns for users prioritizing convenience and long-term value.
Mood-color glow
USB powerbank
Cordless warm-tone
USB-C rechargeable internal battery with long runtime and no fuel required
Up to 500 lumens with adjustable warmth and dimming modes for versatile lighting
Mood-color glow
USB powerbank
Cordless warm-tone
USB-C rechargeable internal battery with long runtime and no fuel required
Up to 500 lumens with adjustable warmth and dimming modes for versatile lighting
Primus Micron Lantern
The Primus Micron Lantern is positioned as the ultralight, fuel-efficient choice for backcountry users who need compact, reliable gas lighting from small screw-on canisters. It is technically optimized for weight and fuel economy compared with heavier high-output options like the Coleman Northstar or the dual-fuel Coleman, and while its upfront cost per lumen can be higher than a simple candle lantern, it provides superior performance for minimalist technical trips where carry weight matters.
Featherweight size
Ultra-compact pack
Featherweight size
Ultra-compact pack
Review Summary
"Favored for its compact, lightweight design and usable fuel-powered light, but many reviewers find output limited compared with larger lanterns and cite mantle/parts durability concerns with heavy, prolonged use."
Tiny-titan flame
Compact, lightweight design that runs on standard isobutane–propane canisters
Tiny-titan flame
Compact, lightweight design that runs on standard isobutane–propane canisters
Recreational Enjoyment
Skill Development & Mastery
The Primus Micron Lantern is positioned as the ultralight, fuel-efficient choice for backcountry users who need compact, reliable gas lighting from small screw-on canisters. It is technically optimized for weight and fuel economy compared with heavier high-output options like the Coleman Northstar or the dual-fuel Coleman, and while its upfront cost per lumen can be higher than a simple candle lantern, it provides superior performance for minimalist technical trips where carry weight matters.
Featherweight size
Ultra-compact pack
Tiny-titan flame
Compact, lightweight design that runs on standard isobutane–propane canisters
Adjustable flame output for controlling brightness and burn time
Featherweight size
Ultra-compact pack
Tiny-titan flame
Compact, lightweight design that runs on standard isobutane–propane canisters
Adjustable flame output for controlling brightness and burn time
Coleman Premium Dual Fuel Lantern
The Coleman Premium Dual Fuel Lantern is a best-in-class choice when fuel flexibility and long runtime are priorities, because it burns white gas (and can accept fuels like gasoline with proper use) to deliver sustained, high-intensity light in remote conditions. It offers a financial and logistical advantage over propane-only models in long expeditions or areas where liquid fuel is cheaper or more available, though it is heavier and requires more maintenance than electric or candle options on the list.
Dual-fuel flexibility
Blazing high-output
Dual-fuel flexibility
Blazing high-output
Review Summary
"Highly rated for very bright, dependable light and fuel flexibility (white gas or propane with an adapter); long-term users praise its durability, though it’s bulky and requires periodic maintenance."
Vintage camp-charisma
Runs on Coleman fuel (white gas) or unleaded gasoline for field flexibility
Vintage camp-charisma
Runs on Coleman fuel (white gas) or unleaded gasoline for field flexibility
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
Skill Development & Mastery
The Coleman Premium Dual Fuel Lantern is a best-in-class choice when fuel flexibility and long runtime are priorities, because it burns white gas (and can accept fuels like gasoline with proper use) to deliver sustained, high-intensity light in remote conditions. It offers a financial and logistical advantage over propane-only models in long expeditions or areas where liquid fuel is cheaper or more available, though it is heavier and requires more maintenance than electric or candle options on the list.
Dual-fuel flexibility
Blazing high-output
Vintage camp-charisma
Runs on Coleman fuel (white gas) or unleaded gasoline for field flexibility
Classic mantle lantern brightness with adjustable light control for large-group illumination
Dual-fuel flexibility
Blazing high-output
Vintage camp-charisma
Runs on Coleman fuel (white gas) or unleaded gasoline for field flexibility
Classic mantle lantern brightness with adjustable light control for large-group illumination
GSI Outdoors Candle Lantern
The GSI Outdoors Candle Lantern is the low-cost, low-tech option that excels as an inexpensive backup or mood light, using simple candles instead of pressurized fuel—making it cheap to run and nearly maintenance-free. It cannot compete with gas lanterns for brightness or runtime, but its financial simplicity and robustness make it an attractive complement to the higher-output, higher-cost fuel and gas lanterns in this selection.
Soothing candlelight
Weightless simplicity
Soothing candlelight
Weightless simplicity
Review Summary
"Appreciated for simple, quiet ambient light, portability and low cost, but reviewers consistently note it is dim, wind-sensitive, and not suitable as a primary light source."
Old-world calm
Uses standard tealight candles for ultra-simple, fuel-free operation
Old-world calm
Uses standard tealight candles for ultra-simple, fuel-free operation
Recreational Enjoyment
Eco-Friendly Living
The GSI Outdoors Candle Lantern is the low-cost, low-tech option that excels as an inexpensive backup or mood light, using simple candles instead of pressurized fuel—making it cheap to run and nearly maintenance-free. It cannot compete with gas lanterns for brightness or runtime, but its financial simplicity and robustness make it an attractive complement to the higher-output, higher-cost fuel and gas lanterns in this selection.
Soothing candlelight
Weightless simplicity
Old-world calm
Uses standard tealight candles for ultra-simple, fuel-free operation
Very lightweight and compact—great for ambient table or campsite light
Soothing candlelight
Weightless simplicity
Old-world calm
Uses standard tealight candles for ultra-simple, fuel-free operation
Very lightweight and compact—great for ambient table or campsite light