Dorman 610-458 Extended Wheel Stud
The Dorman 610-458 is a practical, budget-friendly extended wheel stud option built as an OE-style replacement for horse trailers that need extra thread length. It holds its position as the best value choice on this list by offering wide availability and direct-fit convenience at a significantly lower price than premium fasteners like ARP or McGard, while still delivering adequate strength for normal towing loads. Compared with higher-end alloy studs, Dorman trades ultimate tensile performance for affordability and easy replacement serviceability.
OEM-style fit
Budget-friendly pick
OEM-style fit
Budget-friendly pick
Review Summary
"Users report the Dorman 610-458 fits well as an affordable OEM-style replacement and performs satisfactorily for regular trailer use, though some note variation in finish and occasional fitment tweaks needed. Overall buyers appreciate the value but say it's not as robust as premium aftermarket studs."
Trailer-ready hug
Economical aftermarket option offering extended length suitable for trailer hub applications.
Trailer-ready hug
Economical aftermarket option offering extended length suitable for trailer hub applications.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Time-Saving Convenience
The Dorman 610-458 is a practical, budget-friendly extended wheel stud option built as an OE-style replacement for horse trailers that need extra thread length. It holds its position as the best value choice on this list by offering wide availability and direct-fit convenience at a significantly lower price than premium fasteners like ARP or McGard, while still delivering adequate strength for normal towing loads. Compared with higher-end alloy studs, Dorman trades ultimate tensile performance for affordability and easy replacement serviceability.
OEM-style fit
Budget-friendly pick
Trailer-ready hug
Economical aftermarket option offering extended length suitable for trailer hub applications.
Heat-treated steel construction for basic durability under typical trailer loads.
OEM-style fit
Budget-friendly pick
Trailer-ready hug
Economical aftermarket option offering extended length suitable for trailer hub applications.
Heat-treated steel construction for basic durability under typical trailer loads.
$40-80 CAD
ARP 100-7716 Extended Wheel Studs
The ARP 100-7716 Extended Wheel Studs are the market leader for strength and reliability, engineered from high-strength alloy and heat-treated to withstand heavy loads typical of horse trailers hauling multiple animals or heavy gear. ARP holds a technical advantage over the other products by prioritizing tensile and shear capacity—making them the best choice where safety margins and fatigue resistance are critical—albeit at a premium price compared with economy options like Dorman and Gorilla. For owners who tow frequently or operate in demanding conditions, ARP's performance justifies the higher upfront cost versus mid-range alternatives.
Race-grade strength
Exact threading
Race-grade strength
Exact threading
Review Summary
"Buyers praise the ARP 100-7716 for exceptional strength, precise threads, and long-term durability under heavy towing conditions; it's widely chosen for reliability and peace of mind. Installers consistently report excellent fit and longevity with no corrosion issues when maintained properly."
Torque-monster grin
ARP premium alloy formulation and precision threading designed for maximum clamping force.
Torque-monster grin
ARP premium alloy formulation and precision threading designed for maximum clamping force.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Skill Development & Mastery
The ARP 100-7716 Extended Wheel Studs are the market leader for strength and reliability, engineered from high-strength alloy and heat-treated to withstand heavy loads typical of horse trailers hauling multiple animals or heavy gear. ARP holds a technical advantage over the other products by prioritizing tensile and shear capacity—making them the best choice where safety margins and fatigue resistance are critical—albeit at a premium price compared with economy options like Dorman and Gorilla. For owners who tow frequently or operate in demanding conditions, ARP's performance justifies the higher upfront cost versus mid-range alternatives.
Race-grade strength
Exact threading
Torque-monster grin
ARP premium alloy formulation and precision threading designed for maximum clamping force.
Engineered for heavy-duty trailer use where wheel retention and load capacity are critical.
Race-grade strength
Exact threading
Torque-monster grin
ARP premium alloy formulation and precision threading designed for maximum clamping force.
Engineered for heavy-duty trailer use where wheel retention and load capacity are critical.
$180-300 CAD
Gorilla Automotive 44138XL Extended Thread Wheel Studs
The Gorilla Automotive 44138XL Extended Thread Wheel Studs present a strong mid-market option, offering longer threads and durable plating that often deliver better corrosion resistance than entry-level studs without matching ARP's tensile rating. They stand out as a cost-effective compromise—more robust and better finished than many economy replacements, yet noticeably less expensive than McGard or ARP—making them attractive for trailer owners who want improved longevity on a modest budget. Compared to Dorman, Gorilla typically focuses more on finish and durability, while ARP still leads on raw strength.
Heavy-duty toughness
Corrosion-resistant finish
Heavy-duty toughness
Corrosion-resistant finish
Review Summary
"The Gorilla Automotive 44138XL is viewed as a good-value extended-stud option that installs easily and holds up well for most trailer uses, though a minority of users mention occasional variability in finish or straightness. For cost-conscious buyers it’s seen as a reliable alternative to premium brands."
Gorilla-grip hold
Extended thread length accommodates thicker wheel spacers or dual-wheel setups common on trailers.
Gorilla-grip hold
Extended thread length accommodates thicker wheel spacers or dual-wheel setups common on trailers.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Time-Saving Convenience
The Gorilla Automotive 44138XL Extended Thread Wheel Studs present a strong mid-market option, offering longer threads and durable plating that often deliver better corrosion resistance than entry-level studs without matching ARP's tensile rating. They stand out as a cost-effective compromise—more robust and better finished than many economy replacements, yet noticeably less expensive than McGard or ARP—making them attractive for trailer owners who want improved longevity on a modest budget. Compared to Dorman, Gorilla typically focuses more on finish and durability, while ARP still leads on raw strength.
Heavy-duty toughness
Corrosion-resistant finish
Gorilla-grip hold
Extended thread length accommodates thicker wheel spacers or dual-wheel setups common on trailers.
Carbon steel with zinc plating offers a balance of strength and corrosion resistance.
Heavy-duty toughness
Corrosion-resistant finish
Gorilla-grip hold
Extended thread length accommodates thicker wheel spacers or dual-wheel setups common on trailers.
Carbon steel with zinc plating offers a balance of strength and corrosion resistance.
$40-90 CAD
DPAccessories D3116-2305 Extended Wheel Studs
The DPAccessories D3116-2305 extended studs are positioned as a practical aftermarket kit tailored to trailer owners who need direct-fit extended studs in multi-piece sets for maintenance or upgrades. This product emphasizes package convenience and compatibility, often offering a middle-ground cost and selection flexibility versus single-piece premium options like ARP and McGard, making it a smart choice for fleet owners or hobbyist equestrians replacing several studs at once. Technically it competes by delivering acceptable strength and fitment while keeping per-stud cost lower than the top-tier alloys.
Long-thread reach
Hardened steel
Long-thread reach
Hardened steel
Review Summary
"Customers find the DPAccessories D3116-2305 functional and affordable for light to moderate trailer duties, but some report mixed long-term durability and occasional fitment inconsistencies. It’s generally considered acceptable for budget installs but not top-tier for heavy, repeated towing."
Hauler's bestie
Designed with multiple length and thread options to match varied trailer hub configurations.
Hauler's bestie
Designed with multiple length and thread options to match varied trailer hub configurations.
Time-Saving Convenience
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
The DPAccessories D3116-2305 extended studs are positioned as a practical aftermarket kit tailored to trailer owners who need direct-fit extended studs in multi-piece sets for maintenance or upgrades. This product emphasizes package convenience and compatibility, often offering a middle-ground cost and selection flexibility versus single-piece premium options like ARP and McGard, making it a smart choice for fleet owners or hobbyist equestrians replacing several studs at once. Technically it competes by delivering acceptable strength and fitment while keeping per-stud cost lower than the top-tier alloys.
Long-thread reach
Hardened steel
Hauler's bestie
Designed with multiple length and thread options to match varied trailer hub configurations.
Durable heat-treated construction suited to repeated trailer loading and towing stresses.
Long-thread reach
Hardened steel
Hauler's bestie
Designed with multiple length and thread options to match varied trailer hub configurations.
Durable heat-treated construction suited to repeated trailer loading and towing stresses.
$50-120 CAD
McGard 65357 Chrome Extended Thread Wheel Studs
The McGard 65357 Chrome Extended Thread Wheel Studs are a premium, corrosion-conscious choice that combine solid mechanical performance with a high-quality chrome finish suited to horse trailers that frequently encounter road salts or wet environments. McGard occupies a leader position for finish and long-term corrosion protection compared with raw or zinc-plated alternatives like Dorman and Gorilla, and while their tensile strength is excellent for trailer use, ARP remains the go-to where maximum strength is the single priority. For trailer owners who value appearance and long-term durability in addition to strength, McGard offers strong overall value despite a higher price point.
Premium chrome finish
Precision-engineered fit
Premium chrome finish
Precision-engineered fit
Review Summary
"McGard 65357 receives high marks for precision, corrosion-resistant chrome finish, and long-term reliability; users say these studs provide a professional fit and lasting performance under heavy use. They’re frequently recommended for those wanting premium OEM-quality replacement hardware."
Showroom-ready shine
Chrome-plated finish provides enhanced corrosion resistance for outdoor trailer environments.
Showroom-ready shine
Chrome-plated finish provides enhanced corrosion resistance for outdoor trailer environments.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
The McGard 65357 Chrome Extended Thread Wheel Studs are a premium, corrosion-conscious choice that combine solid mechanical performance with a high-quality chrome finish suited to horse trailers that frequently encounter road salts or wet environments. McGard occupies a leader position for finish and long-term corrosion protection compared with raw or zinc-plated alternatives like Dorman and Gorilla, and while their tensile strength is excellent for trailer use, ARP remains the go-to where maximum strength is the single priority. For trailer owners who value appearance and long-term durability in addition to strength, McGard offers strong overall value despite a higher price point.
Premium chrome finish
Precision-engineered fit
Showroom-ready shine
Chrome-plated finish provides enhanced corrosion resistance for outdoor trailer environments.
Forged and heat-treated for high strength and long service life under towing conditions.
Premium chrome finish
Precision-engineered fit
Showroom-ready shine
Chrome-plated finish provides enhanced corrosion resistance for outdoor trailer environments.
Forged and heat-treated for high strength and long service life under towing conditions.
$120-240 CAD