Fresh Step Simply Unscented Lightweight Litter
A widely distributed, budget-friendly choice, Fresh Step Simply Unscented Lightweight holds a market-leader position because of its strong retail presence and low per-bag cost. For the disposable-tray, non-clumping use case it ranks lower technically than paper or pellet options because its clay-based lightweight formula can compact and cling in a shallow disposable tray, though its price and availability make it an easy default for many owners.
Feather-light scoop
Neutral-scent ninja
Feather-light scoop
Neutral-scent ninja
Review Summary
"Long-term users say Fresh Step Simply Unscented Lightweight controls odor well for a lightweight clumping option and is easy to scoop, though some report more tracking and occasional dust than promised. Most buyers appreciate the unscented formula but a minority switch for stronger odor control or lower tracking."
Dust-minimal buddy
Lightweight formulation reduces lifting and carrying weight for users
Dust-minimal buddy
Lightweight formulation reduces lifting and carrying weight for users
Time-Saving Convenience
Increased Safety & Security
A widely distributed, budget-friendly choice, Fresh Step Simply Unscented Lightweight holds a market-leader position because of its strong retail presence and low per-bag cost. For the disposable-tray, non-clumping use case it ranks lower technically than paper or pellet options because its clay-based lightweight formula can compact and cling in a shallow disposable tray, though its price and availability make it an easy default for many owners.
Feather-light scoop
Neutral-scent ninja
Dust-minimal buddy
Lightweight formulation reduces lifting and carrying weight for users
Clumping clay formula creates firm clumps for scoop-and-clean maintenance
Feather-light scoop
Neutral-scent ninja
Dust-minimal buddy
Lightweight formulation reduces lifting and carrying weight for users
Clumping clay formula creates firm clumps for scoop-and-clean maintenance
$12-20 CAD
Purina Yesterday's News Original Paper Cat Litter
Purina Yesterday's News is best-in-class for disposable-tray compatible, non-clumping litters thanks to its recycled paper composition, low dust, and absorbent, non-tracking pellets that suit single-use trays. Compared with clay, pine, or clumping pea husk products on this list, it offers a stronger balance of absorbency and low maintenance for disposable setups, albeit sometimes at a slightly higher price than commoditized pine options.
Paper-soft pellets
Flushable wink
Paper-soft pellets
Flushable wink
Review Summary
"Customers who use Purina Yesterday's News for extended periods praise its low dust and gentle paper texture that’s good for sensitive cats, but many note it requires more frequent full changes and provides weaker odor control compared with clay litters. It’s favored for litters boxes and disposable trays but not ideal for multi-cat households."
Low-tracking trail
Made from recycled paper pellets that are non-clumping and highly absorbent
Low-tracking trail
Made from recycled paper pellets that are non-clumping and highly absorbent
Time-Saving Convenience
Increased Safety & Security
Purina Yesterday's News is best-in-class for disposable-tray compatible, non-clumping litters thanks to its recycled paper composition, low dust, and absorbent, non-tracking pellets that suit single-use trays. Compared with clay, pine, or clumping pea husk products on this list, it offers a stronger balance of absorbency and low maintenance for disposable setups, albeit sometimes at a slightly higher price than commoditized pine options.
Paper-soft pellets
Flushable wink
Low-tracking trail
Made from recycled paper pellets that are non-clumping and highly absorbent
Effective odor control for short-term use in disposable trays
Paper-soft pellets
Flushable wink
Low-tracking trail
Made from recycled paper pellets that are non-clumping and highly absorbent
Effective odor control for short-term use in disposable trays
$18-30 CAD
Catit Go Natural Pea Husk Clumping Cat Litter
Catit Go Natural Pea Husk stands out for its biodegradable, low-dust formulation and strong clumping performance, giving it a technical advantage in odor-locking and scoopability. However, because it is a clumping litter it is less naturally aligned with disposable-tray workflows than the non-clumping paper and pine options here — it excels environmentally and for multi-day boxes, but may complicate single-use tray disposal.
Pea-power absorb
Biodegrade buddy
Pea-power absorb
Biodegrade buddy
Review Summary
"Reviewers of Catit Go Natural Pea Husk find it appealing as a plant-based clumping option with decent clump integrity and low dust, though long-term users sometimes report modest odor control and occasional clump break-up. Many like the eco-friendly angle, but some return to stronger-odor litters for heavy use or multi-cat homes."
Odor-lock champion
Biodegradable pea-husk formula designed to clump for easy scooping
Odor-lock champion
Biodegradable pea-husk formula designed to clump for easy scooping
Time-Saving Convenience
Increased Safety & Security
Catit Go Natural Pea Husk stands out for its biodegradable, low-dust formulation and strong clumping performance, giving it a technical advantage in odor-locking and scoopability. However, because it is a clumping litter it is less naturally aligned with disposable-tray workflows than the non-clumping paper and pine options here — it excels environmentally and for multi-day boxes, but may complicate single-use tray disposal.
Pea-power absorb
Biodegrade buddy
Odor-lock champion
Biodegradable pea-husk formula designed to clump for easy scooping
Clumping action improves scoopability but is incompatible with disposable tray disposal
Pea-power absorb
Biodegrade buddy
Odor-lock champion
Biodegradable pea-husk formula designed to clump for easy scooping
Clumping action improves scoopability but is incompatible with disposable tray disposal
$12-25 CAD
Arm & Hammer Feline Pine Non-Clumping Cat Litter
Arm & Hammer Feline Pine is a cost-effective, non-clumping alternative that uses natural pine to control odors and stays lightweight for easy handling — traits that make it a practical choice for disposable tray users seeking low-dust, biodegradable options. Compared to paper pellets it is generally more affordable and provides better pine-scented odor control, though paper litters can outperform it on pure absorbency and reduced tracking.
Pine-fresh punch
No-clump crunch
Pine-fresh punch
No-clump crunch
Review Summary
"Arm & Hammer Feline Pine is commonly praised for low dust, good natural odor masking, and being easy on paws, but frequent users mention tracking of pellets and the need for regular full changes since it doesn’t clump. Fans of non-clumping, disposable-tray setups appreciate its pine scent and minimal chemical additives."
Compost-happy grin
Made from pine materials that naturally neutralize odors
Compost-happy grin
Made from pine materials that naturally neutralize odors
Increased Safety & Security
Time-Saving Convenience
Arm & Hammer Feline Pine is a cost-effective, non-clumping alternative that uses natural pine to control odors and stays lightweight for easy handling — traits that make it a practical choice for disposable tray users seeking low-dust, biodegradable options. Compared to paper pellets it is generally more affordable and provides better pine-scented odor control, though paper litters can outperform it on pure absorbency and reduced tracking.
Pine-fresh punch
No-clump crunch
Compost-happy grin
Made from pine materials that naturally neutralize odors
Non-clumping, absorbent form works well in disposable trays
Pine-fresh punch
No-clump crunch
Compost-happy grin
Made from pine materials that naturally neutralize odors
Non-clumping, absorbent form works well in disposable trays
$15-28 CAD
ökocat Paper Pellet Cat Litter
ökocat Paper Pellet combines premium positioning with strong absorbency and very low dust and tracking, making it highly compatible with disposable trays and non-clumping use. Relative to the other products listed, ökocat typically commands a premium price but returns that with superior eco-friendly credentials and fast absorption that keeps disposable trays drier and easier to replace than many pine or clay options.
Forest-friendly pellets
Pollen-free whisper
Forest-friendly pellets
Pollen-free whisper
Review Summary
"Long-term users of ökocat Paper Pellet like the very low dust and lightweight profile that suits disposable trays, but many say odor control is weaker and pellets need frequent replacement or supplemental deodorizer. It’s popular for sensitive cats and low-dust requirements but less favored in multi-cat or high-odor situations."
Track-free glide
Premium recycled paper pellets offer high absorbency without clumping
Track-free glide
Premium recycled paper pellets offer high absorbency without clumping
Increased Safety & Security
Time-Saving Convenience
ökocat Paper Pellet combines premium positioning with strong absorbency and very low dust and tracking, making it highly compatible with disposable trays and non-clumping use. Relative to the other products listed, ökocat typically commands a premium price but returns that with superior eco-friendly credentials and fast absorption that keeps disposable trays drier and easier to replace than many pine or clay options.
Forest-friendly pellets
Pollen-free whisper
Track-free glide
Premium recycled paper pellets offer high absorbency without clumping
Strong odor control and minimal dust, ideal for disposable tray use
Forest-friendly pellets
Pollen-free whisper
Track-free glide
Premium recycled paper pellets offer high absorbency without clumping
Strong odor control and minimal dust, ideal for disposable tray use
$20-35 CAD